7 Slabs of Alternative Christmas Music You Need in 2025

Alright, let's be honest. If we hear Noddy Holder scream "IT'S CHRISTMAS!" one more time, the telly's going out the window. Christmas is brilliant, but the soundtrack can get a bit… stale. It’s the same old rotation, a musical Groundhog Day sponsored by tinsel and lukewarm mulled wine. What if your festive spirit leans more towards a well-worn band tee than a novelty jumper your aunt knitted you?

Fear not, music lovers. This isn't just another list; it's your official pardon from the tyranny of festive pop. We're diving headfirst into the glorious world of alternative Christmas music – the stuff that lets you rock around the Christmas tree without sacrificing your musical credibility. It’s about having a bit of a laugh, celebrating with tunes that actually mean something to you, and maybe even finding the perfect soundtrack for plastering your walls with some iconic music prints to really make the place your own. After all, a cool print on the wall is like a good tune – it just makes you smile.

This guide is your ticket to a cooler Yule, curated for those who prefer their jingle bells with a side of punk rock, indie melancholy, or metalcore breakdowns. So, pour yourself something strong, stick on a proper record, and let's get this alternative party started.

1. The Cure - "How Beautiful You Are" (Christmas EP)

Let's kick things off with a band that practically invented melancholic cool. While The Cure never bundled up in festive jumpers to record a traditional Christmas album (can you imagine Robert Smith singing "Frosty the Snowman"? Nah, me neither), their influence on the alternative Christmas music scene is massive. Their moody, atmospheric sound provides the perfect antidote to the relentless cheer of mainstream holiday tunes, offering a more introspective and emotionally complex soundtrack for when you've had enough of your relatives.

The track "How Beautiful You Are" might not mention sleigh bells or mistletoe, but its inclusion on a rare "Christmas EP" in some regions cemented its place in goth-rock holiday lore. It captures a bittersweet, romantic feeling that fits perfectly with the reflective, often poignant, mood of a cold December night. It's the kind of song that makes you want to stare out of a frosty window, contemplating life, love, and whether you've bought enough mince pies.

Why It's a Festive Essential

This isn't your nan's Christmas playlist. The Cure’s music resonates with anyone who finds the holidays a little overwhelming and prefers a touch of dark romanticism over saccharine pop. Robert Smith's distinctive vocals and the band's swirling guitars create a vibe that's both haunting and beautiful, ideal for those quiet moments after the chaos of Christmas dinner has subsided. It’s the thinking person's Christmas tune, a sophisticated sonic escape for when the board games get a bit too heated.

How to Weave It into Your Christmas

Creating the right atmosphere is key. Here’s how to get the most out of this alternative Christmas classic:

• Intimate Gatherings: Forget the office party playlist. Stick this on for smaller, more intimate get-togethers with friends who appreciate a bit of 80s indie magic.
• Late-Night Listening: It's the perfect track for Christmas Eve when the house is quiet and the lights on the tree are the only thing illuminating the room.
• Playlist Pairing: Mix it with other atmospheric artists like Cocteau Twins, The Smiths, or even modern acts like The xx to create a cohesive, cool, and distinctly alternative Christmas music playlist.

This track is a reminder that festive feelings don't always have to be jolly. If you appreciate the beauty in melancholy and want your walls to reflect that same iconic vibe, you might fancy a look at this lyric print inspired by The Cure's timeless aesthetic.

2. Bad Religion - "Hark! The Herald Angels Sing" and Christmas Songs

If the thought of another syrupy Christmas carol makes you want to stage-dive into the nearest Christmas tree, then punk rock legends Bad Religion are here to save your festive season. In 2013, they released Christmas Songs, an entire album of holiday standards played with their signature velocity, blistering guitars, and Greg Graffin's unmistakable vocals. It's a glorious, high-octane demolition of everything you thought you knew about Christmas music.

Their version of "Hark! The Herald Angels Sing" is a perfect example of their approach. It takes a song usually sung by a tranquil church choir and injects it with enough raw energy to power Santa's sleigh for a hundred years. The result is surprisingly jubilant, stripping away the commercial polish to reveal a core of pure, unadulterated festive energy. This is Christmas music for people who prefer their celebrations in a mosh pit.

Why It's a Festive Essential

Bad Religion provides the ultimate soundtrack for anyone needing a shot of adrenaline to get through the holiday chaos. It proves that you can celebrate Christmas without sacrificing your punk rock credibility. It’s loud, it's fast, and it’s a brilliant way to annoy any relatives who insist on playing Michael Bublé on a loop. Think of it as a public service.

How to Weave It into Your Christmas

Unleashing punk rock carols requires a bit of strategic planning. Here’s how to introduce some glorious noise into your holiday season:

• Energise Your Prep: Use these tracks to power through wrapping presents or wrestling with the turkey. It's impossible to feel sluggish with these songs blasting.
• Alternative Party Starter: Kick off your holiday gathering with a track or two to let guests know this isn't going to be a stuffy affair. It’s an instant ice-breaker.
• Holiday Workout Mix: Need to burn off those mince pies? Add the entire Christmas Songs album to your workout playlist for an instant burst of motivation.
• Playlist Pairing: Create the ultimate alternative Christmas music playlist by mixing Bad Religion with other punk holiday anthems from bands like The Ramones, The Vandals, and Stiff Little Fingers.

This collection is for those who love the spirit of Christmas but prefer it delivered with three chords and a whole lot of attitude. If your taste leans towards iconic punk anthems, you'll probably appreciate the rebellious spirit captured in this print inspired by "Fairytale of New York".

3. Relient K - "Let It Snow Baby... Let It Reindeer" (2007)

For those who traded in their teenage angst for a bit of festive fun but still want to rock out, pop-punk heroes Relient K have you covered. Their 2007 album, "Let It Snow Baby... Let It Reindeer," is a shot of pure, unadulterated energy that bridges the gap between your rebellious past and the family Christmas do. It’s loud, it’s fun, and it’s unapologetically joyful without being schmaltzy.

Led by the witty lyricism of Matt Thiessen, the band infuses classic carols like "Sleigh Ride" and "Silver Bells" with crunchy power chords and frantic drum fills. The album also features fantastic original tracks, proving that pop-punk and Christmas are a match made in heaven. It’s the perfect soundtrack for wrapping presents with more enthusiasm than precision, or for a festive road trip where you need to stay awake on the motorway.

Why It's a Festive Essential

This album is the ultimate gateway drug to alternative Christmas music. Its high-octane charm appeals to both seasoned punk fans and your relatives who might otherwise be reaching for Michael Bublé. Relient K’s version of the holidays is brimming with a sense of humour and genuine warmth, making it a staple on alternative radio playlists every December. It's lively, accessible, and less likely to get you disowned than, say, a full-on metalcore Christmas album (more on that later).

How to Weave It into Your Christmas

This album is versatile enough to liven up almost any festive occasion. Here’s how to deploy it for maximum impact:

• Family Gatherings: Chuck this on during the post-dinner lull. It's upbeat enough to keep the energy levels high and familiar enough to get everyone from your younger cousin to your cool aunt tapping their feet.
• Holiday Road Trips: The driving beats and singalong choruses are perfect for a long journey home for Christmas. It’s guaranteed to keep spirits bright, even when you're stuck in traffic.
• Playlist Pairing: Slot tracks from this album alongside other upbeat alternative acts like Blink-182, Jimmy Eat World, or The Wombats to create a high-energy festive playlist that keeps the party going.

4. Low - "Christmas" (1999)

Right, let's switch gears to something truly special. If the usual Christmas cheer feels a bit too loud and chaotic, this 1999 album from slowcore pioneers Low is the sonic equivalent of a silent, snowy evening. They didn't just cover Christmas songs; they deconstructed them, stripping away the festive noise to find the haunting, beautiful soul underneath. It’s music that demands you stop, listen, and feel something profound.

The album, simply titled "Christmas", is a masterclass in atmosphere. Their versions of classics like "Silent Night" and the mesmerising original "Just Like Christmas" are sparse, glacially paced, and utterly captivating. It’s the kind of music that fills a room without overwhelming it, perfect for those moments of quiet reflection when you’re nursing a mulled wine and wondering if you can get away with eating another Quality Street. It's less "deck the halls" and more "stare into the fire and contemplate the universe".

Why It's a Festive Essential

This album is a critical darling and a fan favourite for a reason. It offers a genuine alternative to the commercial holiday machine, providing a space for contemplation and genuine emotion. Low’s approach resonates with anyone who finds beauty in quiet and stillness, making it an essential part of any discerning alternative Christmas music collection. It's the album you put on to prove to your mates that you're deep and mysterious.

How to Weave It into Your Christmas

To truly appreciate the beauty of this album, timing and setting are everything. It’s not one for the boisterous family get-together.

• Quiet Christmas Morning: Play this softly as the day begins, before the chaos of unwrapping presents and basting the turkey takes over.
• Contemplative Moments: Ideal for late-night listening with headphones, allowing the subtle harmonies and spacious arrangements to wash over you.
• Playlist Pairing: Create a calming playlist by mixing tracks from this album with other ambient or slowcore artists like Sigur Rós, Mazzy Star, or Bon Iver for the ultimate chilled-out festive vibe.

This is more than just an album; it’s a mood. For a taste of its serene beauty, check out their iconic track "Just Like Christmas".

5. The Vandals - "Oi to the World" (1996)

If your idea of festive cheer involves less carol singing and more circle pits, then The Vandals have the perfect Christmas soundtrack for you. The Southern California punk legends threw a massive, irreverent spanner in the works of traditional holiday music with their 1996 album, Oi to the World!. It's a glorious blast of festive anarchy, proving that you can celebrate Christmas while still being a bit of a scallywag.

The title track, "Oi to the World", has become a bona fide anthem for punk rockers during the festive period. It tells a surprisingly heartwarming story of a Christmas Day truce between punks and skinheads, all set to fast-paced, three-chord chaos. It’s loud, funny, and captures a rebellious spirit that offers a much-needed break from the schmaltz of mainstream Christmas pop. It's the musical equivalent of spiking the eggnog with something much, much stronger.

Why It's a Festive Essential

This track is for anyone who believes Christmas should be fun, loud, and a little bit silly. The Vandals brilliantly combine classic punk rock energy with a humorous, almost sweet, holiday narrative. Its legacy is cemented by its regular airplay on alternative radio stations every December and its status as a staple at punk rock holiday shows. It’s a reminder that the spirit of Christmas can be found in the most unexpected places, even in a mosh pit.

How to Weave It into Your Christmas

Forget the Michael Bublé CD; it's time to inject some proper energy into your festivities. Here’s how to make this track part of your holiday tradition:

• The Pre-Christmas Pint Playlist: This is the perfect song to blast while getting ready for a festive night out with your mates. It sets a boisterous, upbeat tone.
• Alternative Christmas Party: If you’re hosting a gathering for friends who’d rather listen to the Ramones than Mariah Carey, this track is a non-negotiable addition to the playlist.
• Playlist Pairing: Create the ultimate punk rock holiday mix by pairing it with tracks from Bad Religion, the Ramones, and No Doubt (who famously covered "Oi to the World"). This is how you build a truly memorable alternative Christmas music experience.

6. She & Him - "A Very She & Him Christmas" (2011)

Steering away from the moodier side of indie, we have the utterly charming festive offering from duo Zooey Deschanel and M. Ward. Their album, "A Very She & Him Christmas," is a masterclass in vintage-inspired indie pop. It strips back the overproduced gloss of many modern Christmas records, favouring a warm, retro sound that feels like it’s been lovingly recorded on analogue tape. It’s the sonic equivalent of a lovingly hand-knitted, slightly quirky Christmas jumper – but a cool one, not the itchy one your nan gave you.

The album is packed with classic covers like "Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree" and "Have Yourself a Merry Little Christmas," but Deschanel’s sweet, ukulele-led vocals and Ward’s tasteful guitar work give them a fresh, understated feel. It’s nostalgic without being old-fashioned, capturing a timeless holiday spirit that has made it a staple on indie radio stations and the soundtracks of numerous quirky festive films. This is Christmas music for people who appreciate a good cardigan and a well-crafted melody.

Why It's a Festive Essential

This album provides a perfect middle ground for anyone wanting to escape the commercial pop juggernaut but isn't quite ready for a full-blown gothic Christmas. It’s sophisticated, stylish, and full of genuine warmth. She & Him’s approach has solidified their place in the alternative Christmas music canon, proving that you can honour tradition while putting your own unique, indie-folk stamp on it. It’s the go-to album for those who want their festive cheer served with a side of effortless cool.

How to Weave It into Your Christmas

This album is versatile, fitting into numerous holiday scenarios with ease. Here’s how to make it the star of your festive soundtrack:

• Vintage-Themed Gatherings: If you’re planning a holiday party with a retro aesthetic, this album is non-negotiable. It sets a perfectly nostalgic yet modern tone.
• Background Ambience: It’s ideal for playing during Christmas dinner or while wrapping presents. It's engaging enough to be noticed but subtle enough not to overpower conversation about who got the best presents.
• Playlist Pairing: Create a brilliant indie Christmas playlist by mixing tracks from this album with artists like Sufjan Stevens, Bright Eyes, and Belle & Sebastian for a consistently cool and cosy vibe.

7. August Burns Red - "August Burns Red Presents: Sleddin' Hill" (2012)

Right, let's swap the melancholic indie for something with a bit more... well, guts. If you've ever thought your Christmas playlist needed more intricate guitar work and earth-shaking breakdowns, then August Burns Red has the festive gift for you. This American metalcore outfit decided to tackle Christmas head-on, delivering an entire album of instrumental holiday classics re-imagined with technical precision and brutal heaviness.

"Sleddin' Hill" is no joke; it’s a masterclass in musicianship. The band takes familiar tunes like "Jingle Bells" (re-titled "Flurries") and "Carol of the Bells" and injects them with complex riffs, blast beats, and pure metal energy. It's the sound of Santa swapping his sleigh for a double-bass drum kit, proving that Christmas cheer can indeed coexist with a mosh pit. This is the ultimate antidote to the same old crooners you hear in every department store.

Why It's a Festive Essential

This album is for anyone who loves the festive season but finds the typical soundtrack a bit bland. August Burns Red maintains their musical integrity, offering a complex, powerful, and surprisingly joyful listening experience. It has become a cult classic within the metal community, proving that alternative christmas music can come from even the most unexpected genres. It’s loud, it's proud, and it's guaranteed to get your head banging while you're wrapping presents.

How to Weave It into Your Christmas

Unleashing a metalcore Christmas album requires a bit of strategy. Here’s how to make it work:

• The Christmas Workout: Need motivation for a pre-feast workout? The sheer energy of this album is better than any energy drink.
• A Jolt for Your Gathering: If your Christmas party hits a lull, slip "Carol of the Bells" on. It'll either wake everyone up or clear the room – a win-win situation, really.
• Playlist Pairing: Create the ultimate heavy holiday mix by pairing tracks from "Sleddin' Hill" with other metal Christmas covers from artists like Halestorm, Lemmy Kilmister, or Christopher Lee.
• The Headbanger's Hangout: Perfect for a gathering of like-minded mates who appreciate a good breakdown as much as a good mince pie.

This album is a brilliant reminder that festive traditions can be re-imagined in any style. For those who like their music and their walls to reflect a bold and unconventional taste, have a look at our collection of simple alternative lyric prints.

7-Album Alternative Christmas Music Comparison

Title	🔄 Implementation Complexity	⚡ Resource Requirements	📊 Expected Outcomes	💡 Ideal Use Cases	⭐ Key Advantages
The Cure - "How Beautiful You Are"	Moderate – Atmospheric, moody production	Medium – Requires gothic-style sound design	High emotional depth & unique holiday atmosphere	Intimate gatherings, alternative playlists	Appeals to alternative fans, year-round mood
Bad Religion - "Hark! The Herald Angels Sing"	Moderate – Fast punk arrangements	Medium – Energetic band performance	High energy and punk celebration vibe	Alternative holiday parties, workout playlists	Maintains Christmas spirit with punk authenticity
Relient K - "Let It Snow Baby… Let It Reindeer"	Moderate – Pop-punk with polished production	Medium – Professional recording	Accessible & energetic holiday music	Mixed-age gatherings, retail and road trip music	Bridges punk & mainstream, high replay value
Low - "Christmas" (1999)	Low – Minimalist, sparse arrangements	Low – Simple instrumentation	Intimate, contemplative atmosphere	Quiet Christmas moments, focused listening	Critically acclaimed, unique artistic vision
The Vandals - "Oi to the World"	Moderate – Fast punk with humor	Medium – Band performance	Fun, irreverent holiday punk experience	Punk rock holiday parties, humorous music fans	Highly entertaining, quotable lyrics
She & Him - "A Very She & Him Christmas"	Moderate – Vintage indie pop production	Medium – Retro production style	Nostalgic yet fresh indie pop holiday vibe	Vintage-themed parties, indie pop fans	High quality, accessible to mainstream listeners
August Burns Red - "Sleddin' Hill"	High – Technical metalcore instrumental	High – Skilled metal musicianship	Heavy, complex Christmas interpretations	Metal fan workouts, niche metal holiday playlists	Showcases technical skill, unique metal niche

Your New Festive Soundtrack is Sorted

So there we have it. The sonic antidote to a month of Mariah Carey and Michael Bublé on a seemingly endless loop. We’ve journeyed from the melancholic beauty of Low’s minimalist carols to the festive thrash of August Burns Red, proving once and for all that Christmas music can be as diverse, interesting, and full of personality as your own record collection. This isn't just a list of songs; it’s a toolkit for reclaiming the holiday soundscape.

Your festive season doesn't have to sound like the inside of a department store. It can be raw and energetic like The Vandals' "Oi to the World", surprisingly sincere like Bad Religion's punk-rock hymns, or as achingly cool as She & Him's retro-pop. The real takeaway here is about curation. It’s about consciously choosing the atmosphere you want to create, not just passively accepting the one that’s blasted at you from every public speaker.

Building Your Bespoke Holiday Vibe

Creating your perfect alternative Christmas playlist is the first step. Think of it as decorating, but for your ears. Your next move is to apply that same level of personal taste to your surroundings. After all, what’s the point in having a killer soundtrack if your walls are screaming beige?

A home or office that reflects your personality is a year-round goal, but it feels especially important during the festive season. It’s about creating a space that feels authentically you. A well-chosen print on the wall, much like a perfectly selected track from The Cure, is a statement. It says, "I appreciate the classics, but I do things my own way." It’s a nod to your passions, a slice of pop culture that makes you smile, and a guaranteed conversation starter when your mates come over for mince pies and mulled wine.

Think of the connection: the same energy that draws you to a specific band or a legendary football moment is what makes a piece of art resonate. It’s about identity. Whether you’re spinning a vinyl of Sleddin' Hill or hanging a print of your team's greatest victory, you're curating an environment that tells a story. Your story.

This festive season, we encourage you to go beyond the playlist. Curate your entire experience. Let your music be bold, your decorations be unique, and your walls be a gallery of what you love. Ditch the generic, embrace the alternative, and make this Christmas look and sound exactly how you want it to. Have a brilliant one.

---

Ready to make your walls as cool as your playlist? Find the perfect visual counterpart to your alternative soundtrack at Striped Circle. Explore our collection of unique, witty, and stylish music and football prints that are guaranteed to make your space sing.